NEGOTIATING THE BEST SALARY
Like most of the things you’ve been learning in this book,
negotiating a salary is not difficult, but it does require preparation and
practice. By studying and applying appropriate salary-negotiation principles,
you can significantly increase your starting salary. You owe it to yourself to
get the best salary and benefits possible. Salary, respect, and authority are
interwoven.
All jobs have formal or informal salary ranges. Your goal is
to receive an offer and negotiate for the high end of the range. To do so you
must know the salary range for your geographical area. Your primary information
will come from people who are knowledgeable about the field and industry. To
get top dollar you must also clearly be the top choice.
As a rule, if you have a solid background and are making a
job change rather than a career change, go for a 15–20% increase in salary. You
can do this based on the fact that the employer has decided to look outside
rather than promote from within and expects to pay a premium for your
experience, fresh ideas, and potential.
KNOW YOUR
WORTH
The first principle for getting a top salary is to fully sell
your worth to the organization. You do so by demonstrating your ability to make
or save money for the organization, solve problems, or reduce the stress and
pressure that your future boss has been experiencing. Although companies have
formal or informal salary ranges, those ranges are often ignored when someone
with unexpected experience or potential becomes available.
At the early stages of your job search, you should determine
your overall value in the field you are pursuing. Numerous resources exist to
help you. The Occupational Outlook Handbook contains salary ranges
covering about 300 major occupations. The American Almanac of Jobs &
Salaries, by John Wright, is updated every two or three years and provides
excellent information on an even larger range of occupations. Keep in mind,
however, that both of these references provide national figures; salaries in your
geographical area may be considerably higher or lower.
Beyond these tools, the most useful resources for determining
salaries are people, including professional association officials, headhunters,
and people who currently do the type of work you’re interested in. Associations
exist for every career field imaginable. They sometimes produce salary surveys
for the benefit of their members. Even those which don’t can often give you
good information about current salary ranges. To find an appropriate association,
use The Encyclopedia of Associations and National Trade &
Professional Associations of the U.S. These references are available at
most libraries. For local associations ask people in your chosen field what
associations they belong to.
Once you locate an association, attend meetings and talk to
members. With national associations find out if salary surveys are available
and also ask to speak to the person most knowledgeable about salaries.
Headhunters are
another good source of salary information and wage scales because they are
privy to what people are being offered. Many will take two or three minutes
with you to give you some advice. If you choose to call some headhunters,
briefly sell yourself and ask if they are interested in receiving your resume
as well. Recruiting firms and employment agencies often conduct wage surveys
that they make available to the public as part of their marketing. You can call
and ask these firms if they have such surveys available.
Talking to people who do the type of work you want to do can
also provide excellent insight into salary scales. You can usually get this
information over the phone. Explain the purpose of your call, and ask if they
have a couple minutes. Then tactfully ask about salary ranges. You might say something
like, “I’m not asking what you make, but if you could give me a good sense of
how much someone here in the Cleveland area might make with four years’
experience in shipping and receiving, that would really be helpful.” Taking
them off the hook by specifically not asking how much they make
invariably yields better results.
For
a salary search using the Internet, go to Yahoo (www. yahoo. com) and click on
Business & Economy, then click on Salary Information to find appropriate
sites for your type of salary search. Most career web sites now provide salary
information.
Complete your salary research at the beginning of your job
hunt so you know what your career field is paying today. Then you won’t
end up turning down what will later look like a very good offer. Many people
have turned down offers, only to accept something for even less several months
later. This happens most frequently during a recession when many job seekers do
not realize that salaries have fallen. By the same token, salaries tend to rise
during a boom time, so don’t short change yourself if you’re job hunting at a
time when the economy is strong.
KNOW WHAT YOU
NEED
Knowing your worth as well as your financial and
psychological needs is crucial. If you are currently paid well but are
miserable in your job, you would probably be willing to take a pay cut if you
could get greater job satisfaction. The question becomes how much of a cut you
could accept.
To determine your financial needs, establish three budgets.
If you kept track of last year’s expenditures it will be easy. In the left
column you would list all of the categories of expenditures that you have. The
next three columns would consist of: 1) last year’s expenditures; 2) a level of
spending that is less but still comfortable; and 3) a bare-bones budget that
enables you to keep your car and home, but slashes other nonessential items. By
doing this you are not saying you want to live on a bare-bones budget. This
process will simply give you an idea of how low you could go salary-wise and
still maintain a modicum of normalcy.
Next, examine and define what you need in a job regarding
your psychological needs. The right job is one that enables you to utilize your
top skills and strengths. It also allows you to be and express what you already
are, without trying to squeeze you into some pre-existing mold. The right job
should closely match your temperament, values, and motivators. You should also
define the type of organization you want to work for. The organization you work
for is tremendously important and can often make the difference between a good
job and a great job. Take time to define what would make for you a nearly ideal
job, and then determine the lowest salary you would accept if this dream job
was offered to you. Assume you are currently working. How much less than you
are now earning would you accept?
Create a
checklist to help determine how close a particular job is to what you want. On
the next page is Debbie Wilson’s checklist. It provided her with a useful guide
as she evaluated jobs she interviewed for. You can use Debbie’s checklist as a
guide for creating your own checklist. Each item is listed according to its
importance, with the most important things first. Debbie was looking for
accounting management positions. Adapt the items to suit your career focus.
The following items are ones you might want on your list when
defining the type of organization you want to work for:
Good salary
Benefits
Act on employee suggestions
Flexible
Innovative
Potential for advancement
High ethics and integrity
Pleasant physical environment
My own office
Minimal office politics
Pleasant place to work
Casual dress
Tuition reimbursement
Good opportunities for training
Excellent reputation in the industry
Relocation unlikely
Low turnover
Profitable company
Rarely have layoffs
Promotes from within
Facing challenges I’d like to be involved in
Short commute
Hours are reasonable, small amount of overtime
Well-managed organization
Top management is stable
Organization is doing interesting, valuable work
Team emphasis but also work independently
Organization has strong sense of direction
Management is open with staff
Management encourages new ideas
The
list is intended to help you get started. Borrow items, but also come up with
points that are important to you.
If you worked on The Ideal Job
Description, reread What You Should Know About An Organization, as well as what
your wrote about your ideal organization.
|
PRIORITIES
LIST |
definitely meets my needs |
somewhat meets my needs |
does not meet my needs |
unsure at this time |
|
Potential for advancement |
|
|
|
|
|
Company is financially
secure |
|
|
|
|
|
Encourages growth in
employees and pays for professional development classes |
|
|
|
|
|
Teamwork, professional,
friendly atmosphere |
|
|
|
|
|
Allowed to work
independently |
|
|
|
|
|
My boss expresses
appreciation |
|
|
|
|
|
Company has strong sense
of direction, purpose, growth-oriented,
seeks new opportunities |
|
|
|
|
|
Strong integrity and
ethics |
|
|
|
|
|
Company is doing interesting,
valuable work |
|
|
|
|
|
Promotes use of new
computer systems |
|
|
|
|
|
Management is open with
staff |
|
|
|
|
|
Do hands-on work; not just
directing |
|
|
|
|
|
Short commute |
|
|
|
|
|
Work mainly on projects,
with some routine tasks |
|
|
|
|
|
Projects that last several
weeks and are challenging |
|
|
|
|
|
Non-smoking environment |
|
|
|
|
|
Use of both mainframes and
PCs |
|
|
|
|
|
Have my own office |
|
|
|
|
|
Analysis of financial
data, work with management on financial result and setting up action plans |
|
|
|
|
|
Developing and enhancing
Lotus spreadsheets |
|
|
|
|
|
Establishing financial
controls |
|
|
|
|
|
Implementing computer
systems |
|
|
|
|
|
Pay is good |
|
|
|
|
|
Complete benefits |
|
|
|
|
|
Hours are reasonable,
small amount of overtime |
|
|
|
|
|
Stable and respected
management |
|
|
|
|
|
Accounting department is
respected and valued |
|
|
|
|
|
Management encourages new
ideas and frankness |
|
|
|
|
|
Procedures to eliminate
inefficiencies |
|
|
|
|
|
Nice building and physical
environment |
|
|
|
|
|
Size of company 50-500 |
|
|
|
|
|
Casual yet professional
dress policy |
|
|
|
|
Debbie found this checklist very helpful as she
evaluated jobs.
The job she currently has gives her almost everything
she was seeking.
DO NOT DISCUSS
SALARY UNTIL THE JOB IS OFFERED
Discussing your salary requirements before an offer is made
hurts your ability to negotiate. For that reason you should avoid asking about
salary, and you should deflect probes into your current earnings or salary
expectations.
If the job seems challenging, assume it will pay adequately.
Even if it turns out that the job will not pay enough, going through the
interviewing process will at worst cost you some time. The following four
things can happen only if you thoroughly sell yourself throughout the
interviewing process and then go for the job offer:
1. The
job is excellent and it pays what you want.
2. You succeed in convincing the employer that
they need a highly capable person such as yourself, causing them to change the
job description and to bump the salary up a couple notches.
3. You’re overqualified for this position, but an
excellent job in the company opens up a few months later and you are hired.
4. The employer hears of a suitable position with
another company and refers you there.
None of these positive things can happen if you
prematurely terminate the interview process.
If the job seems challenging, it is best to attend the first
interview, learn as much as you can, sell yourself to your fullest ability, and
do everything you can to get a second interview. If you are not interested in
the position, and you believe it will not pay enough, you can always tactfully
decline the offer for a second interview. I would recommend sticking with the
process, however, with the intent of getting an offer. Then see where it can
go. Any one of the four things listed above might happen.
The problem with asking about pay is that the interviewer
will often turn the question around and ask you how much you make or how
much you need to make. When that happens, you’re in trouble. Of the
three things that can happen, only one is positive. If you provide your income
or your expectations, it will either be too high, too low, or about right. If
the figure you give is too high, it will generally be assumed you will not be
interested in the company’s salary range, so the offer won’t be extended. If
you are making considerably less than they are prepared to pay, the assumption
will be that you’re a lightweight. This, too, results in no offer. Or, you
might get the offer but they may lowball you, knowing that what they’re
offering you is 15% below the bottom of their range, but 20% above what you
were making before. They know you will be hard pressed to turn down their
offer.
No matter how you look at it, talking about money before the
time is right confuses things. Frequently of course, it’s the employer who
brings up the issue, so you need to know how to deal with it. Even in the first
interview, the employer may ask you “What are you looking for?” “How much do
you need?” “What’s the minimum amount you’d accept?” or “What range did you
have in mind?” Assuming no offer has been made and that the employer has not
told you the salary range, your response might be “Perhaps we should
concentrate on determining if I’m the right person for the job.” Another
response might be, “I always make it a point not to discuss money until a job
has been offered.” If you’re fairly far along in the interview process you
might add, “Can I assume you’re offering me the position?” Although the
employer was not actually offering a position, more than one job seeker has
heard, “Well, yeah, I guess I am.”
Usually these mild deflections work, but some interviewers
persist. If the question comes again, tactfully, but assertively state, “If
you don’t mind, I’d really like to concentrate on making sure I’m the one who
can help you reach your goals. When we accomplish that, I’m sure the
compensation will be fair.” A statement like that will usually work. In using
any of these responses it is important to be as diplomatic as possible.
People are often concerned that these mild deflections will get
an employer angry. When handled tactfully, that rarely happens. If you detect
that the employer is getting angry, you could ask what range has been
set for the position. If the employer provides the range, then indicate whether
your needs will fall within that range.
If the employer
is unwilling to give you the range, and you really are interested in the
position, you might use a wide range by stating, “Probably $28,000 to $35,000
depending on the level of responsibility and benefits.” If you make over $50,000
you might use a $10,000 range.
If the interviewer gives
you a salary range for the position and asks whether the amount would be
acceptable, you owe it to the interviewer to say yes or no. Some managers want
to know immediately whether your salary needs can be met and may pose this
question to you during the first ten minutes of the first interview. Their
rationale is that they don’t want to waste their time or yours. If the range is
acceptable you may want to say something as simple as “The range seems
adequate.” You would not want to sound elated or concerned.
Copyright 1985, 1990, 1995, 2002 by Tom Washington
Career Management Resources
1750 112th NE, Suite C-224
Bellevue, WA 98004
425/454-6982